Seven years ago, when we purchased BHH, it took a little more than 90 days to close. It was so stressful. We had to be out of our rental on our closing date, and we had no real plan B. After a lot of uncertainty, everything eventually fell into place, but with that experience still fresh on my mind, I expected refinancing to take a similar amount of time. I was so surprised to learn that it’s a much quicker process.
As I am writing this, I realize that I did not previously disclose how we are paying for repairs. We are doing a cash-out refi, which I will tell you more about at another time.
Once I learned how quickly this would all happen, I got on the phone with the contractor I want to use. He came over the same day, and he’s preparing a bid. There is a sense of urgency to design these bathrooms that I did not expect. We could be tearing things up as early as late September or early October!
I have carte blanche for finishes in some ways since we are pretty sure BHH did not have “modern” indoor bathrooms when it was built circa 1885. All signs point to the early turn of the century for the primary bathroom and the 1920s to 1930s for the guest bath. So, my main goal is to use mostly timeless finishes, but I’d like to exercise some creativity too. Why not?
Inspiration
Since I don’t want to go to copyright jail, I’ll link most of my favorites rather than offer a photo. I am keeping a Pinterest board of ideas if you’d like to follow along.
Before I start sharing, here are some of my firm(ish) ideas:
- No white grout in either
- No wallpaper in the primary bathroom. (There is already wallpaper in the small bathroom)
- In the primary bathroom, I plan to keep the wainscoting unpainted.
- I really want a vanity in the primary bathroom.
- If I never see another subway tile it will be too soon but, subway tile is super classic so…
I am a huge fan of Heidi Callier’s work for design inspiration, specifically this bathroom. For some reason, I can’t stop looking at penny tile for everything.
Source: The Home Depot
However, I am equally drawn to historic repro mosaic floors too.
Source: Bonnie Hunter of Quiltville
Since there is marble elsewhere in BHH, it would be appropriate to add marble back into the primary bathroom at least.
Source: The Builder Depot
I know it’s a terrible thing to say, but new marble feels somewhat soulless to me. I guess I don’t feel at home until I’ve stained it with coffee or we’ve chipped a piece somewhere. Maybe I feel too much pressure when things are too perfect?
This bathroom in Architectural Digest definitely fuels my light-colored floor dreams.
Mostly, I like the bathrooms we already have, but we need and want to modernize some things to work for family life. So, that’s where we are right now. Feel free to offer your opinion. What kinds of finishes do you like? Is there something you think would look terrific in BHH? How do you feel about subway tiles?
13 Comments
melissa
Looking forward to seeing the new bath. I’m sure it will be as beautiful as the rest of the house @Mytinyestate used hex marble tiles in their servants bath…they did lay them all out in advance to balance the tones. Love Heidi Callier’s work too!
Stacy
Thank you, Melissa!
melissa
Looking forward to seeing the new bath. I’m sure it will be as beautiful as the rest of your home. @Mytinyestate used hex marble tiles in their servants bath…they did lay them all out in advance to balance the tones. Love Heidi Callier’s work too!
Barbara
Those are beautiful bathrooms, in the links. I love penny tile but am starting to be tired of subway tile. I like it when there’s a twist to it, like this kitchen from Daniel Kanter/Manhattan Nest: https://manhattan-nest.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/DanielKanter-manhattannest-bluestone-kitchen-after-16.jpg
Stacy
I loved that kitchen from Daniel too!
Robin
I like penny tile but I have seen a lot of pictures of it poorly installed – if the sheets weren’t lined up perfectly it would drive me crazy.
I have been thinking about renovating my bathroom for a while, and originally I thought I wanted a marble hex floor but now prefer the repro mosaics. Daltile has a guide to all sorts of them:
https://digitalassets.daltile.com/content/dam/Daltile/website/resources/products/pattern-guides/DAL_Keystones_TilePatternGuide.pdf
Have you thought about, or is it possible to move doors or walls to make the both bathrooms available for everyone and not just one for family and one for guests?
Stacy
Thank you for that guide link. I really appreciate it. You are right that penny tiles don’t leave much room for errors.
monica
Yes, penny tile that’s laid where the sheets aren’t quiiiiite lined up would be crazymaking for me too.
I loved the mix of hex and 1″ square tile Nicole (Making it Lovely) used in her 2nd-floor bathroom:
https://www.instagram.com/p/BzwUCL1ntPA/
Also, this historic tile catalog is a GOLDMINE for patterns/pattern inspiration:
https://digital.library.vcu.edu/islandora/object/vcu%3A81
Stacy
Thank you for these links, Monica!
Ragnar
I’m not super-thrilled about subway tile in bathrooms, mainly for two reasons.
A) Where I live, it was never really common in homes, it was mainly used in commercial locations and public transport buildings. Bathrooms and kitchens mostly used rectified 6×6″ tile from the early 1900s through early 1960s.
B) The bevelled edges are annoying for sealing anything against the wall because you’ll always have gaps. I mean how would you fit a shower enclosure to a subway tile wall?
That being said, I do love the looks! I saved as much original tile as I could from an 1883 bakery, white subway tiles with very dark blue accents. The tiles were probably installed during a remodel in the 1920s or 1930s, I seem to remember reading some historic documents about that building and the city requiring a finish that was easy to keep sanitary. The council permission for operating the bakery was quite detailed and included things like ventilation, emergency exits, locker space for employees, the provision of spittoons and posting of signs prohibiting spitting on the floor, etc.!
Stacy
It’s great to hear from you, Ragnar. I have a lot to think about, and I appreciate your thoughts. I will remember to consider the spittoon location! 🙂 I love looking at old commercial spaces.
Liz
I also was worried subway tile was overdone, but I figure in 15 years when everyone is ripping it out to replace it, mine will still look classic in my old house. I went with an oversized tile after seeing it in a forgotten English kitchen. Although if money hadn’t been an issue, I would have picked Clé colored tiles- they’ve got that perfectly imperfect thing going on.
I am 100% in favor of mosaic floor tile, especially since you will be installing it, not me!
Stacy
I’m deep into looking at tile right now. It’s making my head spin. 😀 Clé tiles are gorgeous!