Week five of the One Room Challenge in the lopsided living room involved a lot of painting, and yet, I still have nothing to show for it. However, unlike week four, when I was feeling discouraged, now I can only laugh.
Speaking of week four, thank you for all of the encouraging comments and suggestions on last week’s post. Normally, I like to answer every comment, but I couldn’t make it happen. I am back on track now, so comment away if you like.
Painting Over and Over and Over
Saturday and Sunday, I decided that I would finish the bench alcove, setting the stage for the rest of the room. I put another coat of black on the sashes and cleaned the glass. Then, I painted the walls Woodmont Cream to match the trim.
I was super happy with the black sashes, but my son kept telling me the living room looked like a panda. I also received loads of messages on Instagram about how I was not moving in the right direction–Take an interior design course. Learn color theory. Take a look at ______’s room. They know what they are doing. By Sunday night, I shut down completely. Again, keep in mind that I am laughing now. My coping methods are healthy, and in no way am I saving lives. This is just a recap of how things went down during week five.
So Monday, I got out of bed, determined to crack the code for our living room, and put this project behind me. I swatched many different white shades from my basement stash, but none went with the cream. My favorite beige looked like lavender. I ran to the paint store for more samples. The pinks were too peach. The whites were too cool. So, I got the brilliant idea to choose a darker shade from the Woodmont Cream paint chip. My idea was foolproof! I knew that the undertones would definitely play well together, and I love warm colors. Inspired, I bought a quart of Vellum and got to work.
One-third into it, I was thinking, I am freaking brilliant. This is gorgeous. Halfway through, my thoughts were, It’s…good–warm. I like it. By two-thirds, I was in a second-guessing kind of mood, but I also thought, I’ve come this far. I’ll see it through. I finished the wall, stood back, and thought, What have I done?
Yellow. I painted it yellow.
Calling in the Reinforcements
Me: Um, Andy, can you come look at this?
Andy: (sees it) Oh.
Me: What do you think?
Andy: (not wanting to hurt my feelings) Well…
Me: You don’t like it?
Andy: Uh…
Me: (to my son) Can you come down here and look at this?
Son: Sure. (sees the wall) Oh.
Me: What do you think?
Son: Well…
Me: You can tell the truth.
Son: Well, it’s not really a good color. It doesn’t match anything anywhere.
Me: Sigh…
And that is where I stopped for the week. I am leaving the photo evidence of this nightmare color scenario to remind myself that yellow is bad–very, very bad.
Cracking the Code
This is a crummy place to leave you hanging, so I’ll offer up a little nugget of something to make this post worth your time. I have finally decided to paint the walls my old friend: Agreeable Grey. With all of the light bouncing around throughout the day, Agreeable Grey makes the lopsided living room look warm and cozy, no matter the weather or the season.
I painted above the mantel to show you. (Is it just me, or is this three-color room starting to look like a circa-1980s church basement nursery? All I need is a wallpaper border, and we’re good to go!)
Currently, I am scrounging up all of my colorful artwork to bring the room to life. Believe it or not, I do see the rest of this room in my mind. Now, to make it happen.
There won’t be a reveal next week, but we have all been given an extension until the end of the month. So, we’ll see where we are over the weekend, and I’ll know more by Monday.
Until then, please do check out the other projects on the One Room Challenge blog. The featured designers are describing their design plans, and the other guest participants are elbow-deep into their own delightful dreams and disasters.
30 Comments
Emily R
Sometimes you have to make a few mistakes to realize what will really look good. You got this!
Stacy
Thank you! 😀
Liz
The church basement comment is so specific and accurate! It got me chuckling.
Stacy
All it is missing is a pink wall. 🙂
Melissa
I love the color you settled on (but I also think your initial idea of matching the walls to the trim would be lovely). Sorry to have contributed to your comment overload but I really like where you are going and how the tones and layout are coming together. Good luck and thanks for letting all of us be a part of your process!
Stacy
You don’t owe me an apology at all. 🙂 Slowly, but surely, it is coming together.
Jennifer
Oh Stacy, you always make me laugh! I love your “real person” process. You’ll get there!
Btw, yellow isn’t always bad. My 1962 kitchen is painted with ‘Parchment’, which sometimes reads light yellow, and is quite cheery with white cabinets and old green/white checked linoleum.
Stacy
Thanks, Jennifer! Also, I’m here for a sunny yellow kitchen. Your kitchen sounds like a very happy place to be.
Jenny
I’m sorry you got so many inconsiderate replies. I don’t mind the cream–I think that it was a good idea! I think that’s a really classic look that can work really well in older houses and it was definitely worth a shot to see if it would work for you. 🙂 I like the gray that you’re going with, neutral but warmish, and I look forward to seeing the whole room in that color!
I have a similar problem with yellows–I like yellow rooms a lot but I am personally incapable of picking the right yellow. I can’t ever seem to find one with the right undertones. I have bought a LOT of yellow samples that we ended up not using. My family still teases me for what they call the “pee yellow” that I painted my room in high school (pfft whatever, I liked it 🙂
Stacy
You hit the nail on the head with yellow. It’s such a cheerful color, but it’s nearly impossible to choose the right shade. Pee yellow! 😀 That’s hilarious.
Candice
I love watching your process! Paint is tough, you can swatch and test paint all you want but until it’s on the full wall, you really don’t know.
Stacy
Thank you, Candice. You are so right about swatching and test painting.
monica
Happy to see the couches back in their best spots! I think the room is looking great!
Stacy
They don’t seem to belong anywhere else. 🙂
tim
it’s coming together nicely and love that bench!! can’t wait to see it all next week!
Stacy
Thank you, Tim! 🙂
Sherrill
I for one like your design decisions, even the “yellow.” Back when we could travel, we went to some Baltic countries and I was struck by how much yellow was used. Maybe some climates just need the brighter color to add warmth and cheer. The gray is sure to look perfect when it all comes together.
Stacy
Thanks, Sherrill. I really feel like yellow would look excellent in a smaller house from a different era. It’s such a happy color.
Barbara
Love the Agreeable Gray. Glad you’re so open about your process. I have a shelf of misfit paint colors in my basement., myself. The room is lovely. Go you!
Stacy
Thanks, Barbara! I finally feel like I’m moving in the right direction.
Cecelia
We’ve all been there- betrayed by paint chips. I have the two gallons of “gray” paint — that turned out to be -gulp- a sickly lavender— to prove it.
Oh god, its a horrible sinking feeling to suspect it’s trending wrong, but you have to finish the wall to give it a proper shot.
Good luck, it feels like the end result is going to be beautiful. Just like that gorgeous wallpaper with the oranges. Oh I love that stuff.
Stacy
Why do we keep going when we know it’s going badly? 😀 I can’t seem to stop myself.
PS: I still love the oranges too! Hopefully, I will complete that entry this winter.
SH
Ah, yeah, my living room is yellow. I was going for a pale buttery color, but ended up with something with a garish green undertone. Liked it for the first two hours and then hated it the last few years. So thanks for showing me that it’s not the end of the world Lol. Total confidence that you will work it all out; you have great conflict resolution skills!
Stacy
Thanks, SH. Hopefully, you’ll get a new shade in your living room soon. 🙂
Emily B.
Yes, the church basement comparison made me laugh out loud as well! My goodness gracious you are such a hard worker, Stacy. I wish I could borrow one-tenth of your energy and persistence.
Stacy
I could do myself a favor and work smarter, not harder. 😀
Holly
I love the Agreeable Gray almost as much as I love the “church basement nursery” analogy..
Stacy
🙂 Thanks, Holly!
Nicole Q-Schmitz
Hahaha oh Stacy 🙂 I do really like that this room makeover could end up anywhere 🙂 I’m still on team add more black paint (to the bench wall section and mantel), but I wholeheartedly agree that the walls should be Agreeable Gray (see what I did there?). I think the red blanket?/dog crate cover? is throwing a lot of glow around that side of the room. I know you mentioned a couple of weeks ago that there were a lot of things that couldn’t change/move from this space – but I can’t remember that. Good luck – you’re almost done!
Stacy
Haha! Your comment made me laugh. Following this One Room Challenge project is a wild ride this round.